S.J. Dibai
I can't sum myself up in a mere 500 words. I can only sum up *others* in a mere 500 words. :-)
View all articles by S.J. Dibai
The American music business has an ongoing ebb
and flow: periods in which the recording and broadcasting
industries undergo much consolidation and centralization, and other
periods characterized by deconsolidation and decentralization. That said, we
live in an era in which a few major record companies and affiliated
distributors have a veritable oligopoly on the charts and this is helped no
doubt by the fact that broadcasting is largely controlled by a handful of
conglomerates.
And once upon a time, clubs and bars used to
hire bands to play five, six, or seven nights a week. Let me make this
painfully clear: You could go to the same club and see the same band five, six,
or seven nights in the same week. Maybe that kind of engagement would last for
months at a time. Now, it's a big deal if an act can get a three-date residency
at a venue for one particular month.
I won't discuss why these changes have taken
place because the reasons are numerous and the "why" is not really my
point. My point is that these changes have done a great deal to hurt the
vitality and viability of local music scenes. A less consolidated, less
centralized music business left a lot of room for regional tastes. During the
1950s, '60s, and early '70s there were many records that became hits in one
market, two markets, or a few markets, but not in every key market across America.
While many of these records came out on tiny independent labels with only local
distribution and promotion, a lot of them came out on nationally-successful
indies or even major labels. Sometimes the artists who made these records were
not local to the areas where their records became hits, but in many cases they
were. Radio stations and local TV shows regularly featured local artists
alongside the top national and international hitmakers. As a result, a lot of
locally popular acts had fans assuming they were stars nationwide. I once knew
someone from Pittsburgh
who could not believe that I, a lover of '60s pop music, had never heard of The
Contrails. Turned out they were a local Pittsburgh
group that never made it in Philadelphia—though
to be fair, oldies stations don't play anywhere near as many local hits as they
used to, so even if The Contrails had been popular in Philly, I still might
have missed out on them.
Of course, the exposure some bands used to get
in the local clubs was immeasurably helpful. I don't need to explain how
playing at a well-known venue every night had the effect of raising a band's
profile on a local level. Indeed, the Philadelphia band The Kit Kats (whose
definitive history I wrote) were able to have an extremely lucrative career
based largely on local club residencies during the 1960s; during their
late-1980s reunion, one of their biggest problems was that they couldn’t get
much more than one-nighters.
And that brings me back to my point: local music scenes are getting buried.
I have had countless people tell me that Philadelphia
is no longer a great city for music—and that's wording their sentiments kindly!
Having immersed myself in the Philly music scene, learning more and more about
it every day, I dare say we're in some ways better than we used to be. After
all, it wasn't necessarily the talent of Philly's recording artists that made
the city famous. Patti LaBelle? Sure. Fabian? Absolutely not. It was the music business that made Philly famous: the
heyday of American Bandstand,
legendary record companies like Cameo-Parkway, Jamie/Guyden, Philadelphia
International, the works of hustling producers who cut hot early rock 'n' roll
and trend-setting Philly soul and didn't always need great singers to make
those records. With a few exceptions, Philadelphia’s
music business is no longer high-profile, but Philly today has got acts with
TALENT. So many that I needn't waste my time with any local artist who's just
so-so in order to find local music to support. But how many people even know
about these truly talented Philly artists? They're simply not getting the
attention or exposure they deserve, and as a result a lot of people both in and
outside of Philly have given up on the city.
Local musicians have to take some of the blame
as well. Some of them don't know how to treat their own scenes. Surely Detroit still has a lot of activity, but it's well
publicized that The White Stripes relocated because Jack White felt that he
helped so many people in the Detroit
music community only to have them turn their backs on him or even
betray him. If that is indeed the way things went down, it's as if Jack did a
lot to raise the profile of the Detroit scene
and Detroit's
own musicians didn't care. I guess they were content to let Detroit's present be forever overshadowed by
its glorious past.
Lately I've been discovering more and
more solid artists from other locales that I never thought of as good
places for music. This is one of the benefits of music journalism, but one
should not have to become a music journalist in order to see the vitality of
local music scenes in America
today. And you know what? You don't have to become a music journalist. Go to
the clubs, bars, coffeeshops, theaters, and festivals in your area. Check the
event calendars in the newspapers or on the websites of the entertainment
venues. Go out and see some artists you've never seen before—or at least check
out their MySpace pages when you see their names listed somewhere. You'd be
surprised by what's going on in your neck of the woods, and if a local act from
some other area comes to your town, you might be surprised by what's going on
in their neck of the woods, too. Keep local music alive! Remember: even the
biggest international stars started out somewhere.